• Yeah. Because gambling never had any detrimental effects on society.

          • 1 year

            Bowling stemmed from a gambling ban. It’s gambling if you play a game where you wager money, it doesn’t have to be purely or at all luck based (and technically chess has a luck element since white has an advantage).

            Though there’s a good chance this is just a pretext to stop people engaging in things that might make them too good at thinking for themselves.

            • You can bet on the outcome but that doesn’t make chess itself a game of chance. And you can bet on anything so by that justification you can ban anything.

        • People will gamble whether it is legal or not much like drugs, alcohol, guns etc. You either drag as much of it into the light as possibke and regulate it or you just hope whatever is in the dark is “okay”.

          Personally I am more in favor of the regulation than the hope.

        • Yeah, I’m staunchly for legalization of all “vices” but I’m not going to pretend that they’re harmless and aren’t valid reasons to want to get rid of them besides being a kill joy.

  • 1 year

    Maybe it’s really because chess is one of the traditional ways to escape oppression. There’s more than a few top players that have done so, and speak out about it.

  • 1 year

    Making men who play chess wear hijab might help with this problem.

  • 1 year

    Up next: the Taliban authorities indecisive about it’s next move, after people start betting on what they’ll ban next

  • My only solace when it comes to this regime is that it’s too (edit: in)competent to stay in power for long. Hopefully they collapse sooner than later.

  • For people who dont know, this has to do with how people used to play chess during the early Islam days as it had a gambling component. Anything that contain a dice roll is prohibited. Thats why we see the gambling parts in these news. Modern chess is completely different which is not taking into account by Taliban.

    In addition to how many hours you spend playing a game as you are not suppose to spend hours on unproductive things.

    Also for people who dont know, chess doesnt make you good at critical thinking or enhance your thoughts process. It might have that ability if you mix it as part of other mental activity, but in general playing chess makes you good at chess.

    The main issue, how they plan to enforce that rule.

    • Interesting, I wasn’t aware of that connection of chess and early islam, though I was somewhat aware that during the 17-19th centuries, in Europe and USA at least, dice games were seen as “street gambling”, but card games were not.

      The main issue, how they plan to enforce that rule.

      Given it’s the Taliban, my bet (heh) is on them sending the wives and daughters of players to jail “as a warning”

  • Chess gambling ?

    Is this like computer chess or chess where the board is in a certain configuration, or two dudes just going at it?

    I can’t imagine how you’d make a wager. Unless you, yourself are gambling against someone else. Then I guess it doesn’t matter, but that isn’t really gambling it’s just one person paying another to play chess?

    • …betting on who wins a chess match? A thing that absolutely happens in the betting community?

      Honestly, the list of things people don’t bet on is probably shorter.